Research Article
Enhancing Phytoremediation of CCAContaminated Soils using NPK Fertilizers in Acacia auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia Seedlings
Rathna Kumari BM, and Nagaraja N
1Department of Botany, Government First Grade College, Vijayanagar, Bengaluru, India
2UGC-Malaviya Mission Teacher Training Centre, Bangalore University, Jnana Bharathi Campus, Bengaluru, India
*Corresponding author:Rathna Kumari BM, Department of Botany, Government First Grade College, Vijayanagar, Bengaluru, India Email: bmrathnakumari@gmail.com
Copyright: ©Rathna Kumari BM, and Nagaraja N. 2024. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Article Information:Submission: 18/04/2024; Accepted: 04/06/2024; Published: 08/06/2024
Abstract
The soil amendments are known to reduce the toxicity of heavy metals in soil. A pot experiment was conducted to evaluate the effect of four different concentrations (220:117:140, 440:117:140, 220:117:280 and 440:117:280) of Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Potassium (NPK) and their effects on Acacia
auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia in phytoremediation of CCA compounds. Results showed that the growth and biomass of the seedlings treated with CCA (1000 mg kg-1 soil) were significantly increased with an increase in NPK concentrations. Similarly, the amounts of Cu, Cr, and As found in the roots
of A. auriculiformis at 440:117:2080 mg g-1of NPK were 3.577, 3.070, and 0.094 mg g-1 respectively. Similarly, the quantity of Cu, Cr, and As found in stem and leaves in similar concentrations of NPK were 1.683 and 2.220 mg g-1, 2.600 and 1.913 mg g-1, and 0.077 and 0.085 mg g-1 respectively. Furthermore,
the amount of Cu, Cr, and As found in the roots of C. equisetifolia at similar concentrations of NPK were 1.670, 3.320 and 0.240 mg g-1 respectively. Nevertheless, the amount of Cu, Cr, and As found in stem and leaves were 0.350 and 0.398 mg g-1 and 0.110 and 1.530mg g-1, 2.540 and 0.154 mg g-1 at
440:117:2080 mg of NPK respectively. The higher concentrations of NPK significantly (p≤0.05) increased the biochemical parameters of both the test plants. The maximum amount of total carbohydrates, proteins, and chlorophyll content found in A.auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia were 4.06, 1.61 and 0.28 mg g-1, and 3.575, 1.073 and 0.369 mg g-1 at NPK ratio of 220:117:280 mg kg-1 soil respectively. The present study advocates that the higher concentrations of NPK improve soil properties and plant productivity by reducing heavy metal solubility and the NPK can greatly enhance phytoremediation in CCA-contaminated soils using A. auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia tree species.
Keywords:Acacia auriculiformis; Casuarina equisetifolia; CCA; NPK; Biochemical parameters
Introduction
Heavy metals remain persistent in the soil for a long period
by posing a long-term threat to the environment [1,2]. These
are biologically magnified and affect soil fertility thereby
reducing crop production [3]. Chromated copper arsenate (CCA)
is a wood preservative, used in the protection of timber from
microbial decay and insect damage [4]. The CCA-treated woods
are widely used as construction material resulting in the release
of its components viz Cr. Cu and As in to agricultural fields, which
initiates concern for food safety [5].
Phytoremediation is an effective technology in mitigating
heavy metal contamination of the soil [6]. Plants used in
phytoremediation produce relatively high biomass, tolerant to
metal toxicity and exhibit high metal absorption capacity [7].
Acacia auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia are moderatesized
fast-growing tree species widely distributed in India. They
have a shallow root system and produce huge biomass in short
periods even in dry conditions [8]. These plant species are
potential candidates for the production of huge biomass and
are well adapted to even poor soil conditions [9]. Furthermore,
these species are found to accumulate huge amounts of metals in
their tissues [10]. Since these plant species show better tolerance
to heavy metal stress, they are used in the remediation of CCA contaminated
sites [11].
The chemical enhanced technology helps the uptake of
heavy metals in plants [12]. The immobilization of heavy
metals using different soil amendments is one of the most
effective ways to remediate contaminated soil [13]. Several
chemical amendments have been used for the enhancement of
phytoextraction process[14]. The EDTA and DTPA are known to
increase biochemical constituents in seedlings of A auriculiformis
and C equisetifolia treated with chromated copper arsenate[15].
Nitrogen is constituent of amino acids and is widely applied in
nurseries. The optimization of N, P, and K doses for improved
seedling growth in Eucalyptus species has been reported [16].
The application of 100 ml NPK stimulated 45% shoot biomass and
26% Cr uptake compared with the non-fertilized cultures [17].
Surprisingly, information on the influence of inorganic fertilizers
viz NPK which are required for healthy growth and development
of plants in phytoremediation of CCA in tree plant species is
meagre. The objective of the study was to investigate the influence
of NPK on the growth, biochemical changes and uptake of CCA
components viz Cu, Cr and As in the seedlings of A. auriculiformis
and C. equisetifolia tree species in pot conditions.
Materials and Methods
Plant material:
Experiments on the effect of four levels of inorganic fertilizers
viz. Nitrogen, Phosphorus, and Potassium (NPK) treated with
chromated copper arsenate (1000 mg kg-1 soil) were conducted in
the seedlings of Acacia auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia
species in Bengaluru, India. The healthy seeds of A. auriculiformis
and C. equisetifolia were procured from the Institute of Forest
Genetics and Tree Breeding (IFGTB), Coimbatore, India. The
seeds were surface sterilized with bavistin (50% WP) followed
by a double wash with deionized water. The CCA (1000 mg kg-1
soil) concentration was prepared from commercially available
C-type CCA with a proportion of Cr (CrO3-47.5%), Cu (CuO-
18.5%), and As (As2O5- 35%). Four levels of NPK viz 220:117:140
mg, 440:117:140 mg, 220:117:280 mg, and 440:117:280 mg kg-1
soil were prepared and were applied separately.Pot experiments:
The healthy seedlings of A. auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia
were transplanted from root trainers in plastic pots (2000cc)
filled with a sufficient quantity of air-dried soil mixed with
compost. All the pots were arranged in the greenhouse in four
replications. The potting medium (sand and soil in 2:1, v/v) was
prepared, mixed thoroughly with CCA (1000 mg kg-1 soil) and four
levels of NPK (220:117:140 mg,440:117:140 mg, 220:117:280
mg,and 440:117:280 mg kg-1 soil). The potting medium consisted
of sand and soil (2:1 v/v) without NPK was used as control.
Regular management practices, including sufficient irrigation
and weed control, were performed during the experiments.Quantification of CCA compounds:
After six months, the shoots (stem and leaves) and roots
of the seedlings of each test tree species were harvested and
washed thoroughly with deonized water. The seedling growth
indices in terms of height were measured with measuring tape
and collar diameter was measured with a calliper. The fresh
and dry weights of the seedlings were recorded for each sample
using electronic balance. The dry weights of the seedlings were
measured after oven drying at 65-75o C till the weight becomes
constant. The washed plant samples were separated into shoots
and roots dried and powdered. One gram of the root and shoot
(stem and leaves) were digested in 10 ml acid mixture of 60%
HNO3 and 2 mL 30 % H2O2 in a microwave oven drying at 200±50
C for 20 min. Furthermore, the concentrations of Cu, Cr, and As
accumulated in roots, stems, and leaves were analyzed using an
atomic absorption spectrometer (Shimadzu, AA-6880, Japan).Biochemical analysis:
The amount of total carbohydrates, protein, and chlorophyll
content found in the 6-month-old seedlings of A. auriculiformis
and C. equisetifolia was estimated by spectrophotometric
methods. The leaves separated from each treatment and were
cut into fine pieces and then ground with mortar and pestle. 0.5 g
of fresh leaf powder from each treatment was homogenized with
5 μL of 80% acetone, incubated overnight at room temperature,
and centrifuged at 5000 rpm for 5 min. The supernatant was
made up to 5 μL with 80% acetone and the optical densities
were measured at 645 and 663 nm wavelengths using UV-VIS
Spectrophotometer (Shimadzu, UV-1900, Kyoto, Japan). The
amount of total carbohydrates was analyzed by the Anthrone
method [18]. Similarly, the total protein contents of the seedlings
were determined by Lowry’s method [19]. Furthermore, the
amount of total chlorophyll was estimated using Arnon’s method
[20] and the results obtained in different treatments were
compared with the control samples.Statistical analysis:
The experimental data on seedling growth, biomass,
accumulation of Cu, Cr and As compounds in root, stem and leaves,
and changes in total carbohydrates, proteins, and chlorophyll
content of A. auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia on exposure to
different NPK concentrations treated with CCA (1000 mg kg-1
soil) were statistically analyzed by one-way analysis of variance
(ANOVA). The data are presented as mean, standard error and
coefficient of deviation (CD) (0.05). Furthermore, different
treatments of the study were analyzed statistically for significant
differences at p≤0.05 by Duncan’s multiple range test (DMRT).Results
Fertilizers on growth and biomass of the seedlings:
The growth and biomass of the seedlings of A. auriculiformis
and C. equisetifolia treated with four different concentrations of
NPK along with CCA (1000 mg kg-1 soil) were varied [Table 1] .
Table 1. Effect of various levels of NPK treated with 1000 mg chromated copper arsenate (CCA) on growth and biomass of Acacia auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia seedlings.
The height and collar diameter of the seedlings were significantly
(p≤0.05) increased with an increase in NPK concentrations.
The maximum and minimum height and collar diameter of A.
auriculiformis recorded were 68.75 and 44 cm and 69.75 cm
and 5.38 and 5.10 cm at NPK concentration of 440:117:280 and
control respectively. Similarly, the highest and lowest height and
collar diameter of C. equisetifolia recorded were 69.75 and 44.25
cm and 4.38 and 3.37 cm at NPK ratio of 440:117:280 and control
respectively. Furthermore, the maximum and minimum fresh and
dry weights of A. auriculiformis were found to be 27.39 and 16.15
mg and 16.17 and 10.29 g in NPK concentration of 220:117:280
25.15 and control respectively. Similarly, the maximum and
minimum fresh and dry weight of C. equisetifolia were found to be
32.82 and 20.23 mg and 13.61 and 8.40 g in NPK concentration of
220:117:280 25.15 and control respectively.
Fertilizers on biochemical parameters of seedlings:
The soil rich in sufficient nutrients are required for the
healthy growth and development of plants. However, the
soil contaminated with toxic heavy metals may affect the
morphological and biochemical parameters of plants. The
influence of different concentrations of NPK on the biochemical
parameters of the seedlings of A. auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia
is presented in [Table 2] . The results showed a gradual increase
in total carbohydrate, protein, and chlorophyll content with an
increase in NPK concentrations. The minimum and maximum
amount of total carbohydrates, proteins and chlorophyll content
recorded in the seedlings of A. auriculiformis were 3.04 and
4.06 mg g-1, 0.95 and 1.61mg g-1 and 0.20 and 0.28 mg g-1 in
control and 220:117:280 mg kg-1 soil concentrations of NPK
respectively. Similarly, the minimum and maximum amount of
total carbohydrates, proteins and chlorophyll content recorded
in the seedlings of C. equisetifolia were 2.475 and 3.575 mg g-1,
0.826 and 1.073mg g-1 and 0.210 and 0.369 mg g-1 in control and
220:117:280 mg kg-1 soil concentrations of NPK respectively.Fertilizers on bioaccumulation of CCA compounds in the seedlings:
Plants respond differently to fertilizers depending on
their ability to accumulate heavy metals in shoots and root.
Accumulation of CCA in the form of its components viz Cu,
Cr, and As amended with different concentrations of NPK
were recorded in the root of six months old A. auriculiformis
seedlings [Table 3] . The results revealed a significant (p≤0.05)
increase in accumulation of CCA compounds with an increase
in concentration of NPK in both root and shoot. The highest
amounts of Cu, Cr, and As found in the root were 5.027, 4.207,
and 0.147 mg g-1 respectively at 220:117:280 NPK level. Similarly,
the maximum amount of Cu, Cr, and As recorded in stem and
leaves were 2.333, 3.623, and 0.117 mg g-1 and 3.343, 3.650, and
0.134 mg g-1 respectively in the similar concentration of NPK.The amount of CCA components viz Cu, Cr, and As amended
with different concentrations of NPK were recorded in the root,
stem, and leaves of the seedlings of C. equisetifolia [Table 4] .
The observations showed a significant (p≤0.05) increase in the
amount of CCA compounds with an increase in concentration of
NPK in both stem and leaves. The maximum amount of Cu, Cr,
and As found in the root were 3.650, 4.230, and 0.329 mg g-1
respectively at 220:117:280 NPK level. Similarly, the maximum
amount of Cu, Cr, and As recorded in stem and leaves were
0.645, 0.874, and 0.198 mg g-1 and 2.870, 3.870, and 0.242 mg g-1
respectively in the similar concentration of NPK.
Discussion
The addition chemical amendments to soil contaminated
with heavy metals enhance the phytoremediation process, and
fertilizers are the most widely used amendments[21]. Reports
show that the mobility of metals in the soil can be considerably
increased by the addition of chelating agents. A number of natural
and synthetic chelating agents are available, although their
effectiveness varies with plant and soil types. The results of the
study showed an increased growth and biomass of the seedlings
treated with NPK in CCA-contaminated soils. It is apparent that
fertilizers enhance the plant growth, and heavy metal extraction
capacity of plants [22]. The increase in seedling height on
application of nitrogen might lead to increased production of
photosynthesis [23]. There was an increase in the mean plant
biomass and tolerance, on treated with fertilizers in Pb, Cd and
Table 2.Effect of various levels of NPK treated with 1000 mg chromated copper arsenste (CCA) on carbohydrate, protein and chlorophyll content of Acacia auriculiformis and Casuarina equisetifolia seedlings.
Table 3. Effect of various levels of NPK treated 1000 mg chromated copper arsenate (CCA) on accumulation Copper, Chromium and Arsenic content in Stem, Root and Leaves of Acacia auriculiformis seedlings at six month age.
Table 4. Effect of various levels of NPK treated with 1000 mg chromated copper arsenate (CCA) on accumulation of Copper, Chromium and Arsenic content in Stem, Root and Leaves of Casuarina equisetifolia seedlings at six month age.
Zn-contaminated soils [24]. The observations of [25] showed
that the addition of NPK fertilizers significantly increased the
biomass of Leersia hexandra with higher Cu extraction efficiency.
Nitrogen plays an important role in plant growth since N is a
component of all plant structures such as proteins, enzymes, and
chlorophyll. Appropriate fertilization could increase the plant
biomass content and may enhance their ability to uptake and
tolerate heavy metals [26].
Nutrient solutions were applied to the soil to improve the
growth of plants for phytoremediation.Furthermore, nutrient
availability is an important factor governing the success of
phytoremediation and can be regulated through the addition of
fertilizers.Several studies showed that the application of NPK
significantly increase heavy metal uptake in plants. Phosphorus
contributes to root expansion and plant nutrient uptake [27].The
increased accumulation of CCA in the seedlings could be attributed
to the increased solubility of CCA compounds in the soil. Urea
was found to enhance the Cd phytoaccumulation in Carpobrotus
rossii [28]. Furthermore, nitrogen application reduces the
production of a large number of reactive oxygen species (ROS)
induced by biotic and abiotic stress [29]. Nitrogen fertilizers
improve the resistance and tolerance to plants exposed to Cd
stress [30]. Similarly, Cd phytoremediation efficiency of Solanum
nigrum was found to be improved with the addition of nitrogen
fertilizer [31]. The N, P, and K are important components of plant
amino acids, proteins, genetic material, and enzymes [32].
It is evident from the studies that, the NPK enhances the
biochemical composition of A. auriculiformis and C. equisetifolia
seedlings. Results of the study showed increased amount of
carbohydrate content, proteins and chlorophyll content with
an increase in the concentrations of NPK in the seedlings of
test species. The reactive oxygen species (ROS) causes severe
changes in protein structure, altering the proteins’ functions,
with subsequent effects on metabolic pathways [33]. The
results of our study showed an increase in the chlorophyll
content in the seedlings exposed to different concentrations
of NPK. Accumulation of excess amounts of Cu damages the
ultra-structure of the chloroplast, which directs changes in the
composition of the thylakoid membrane [34].
Conclusion
The studies reveal that the NPK plays a pivotal role in the
enhancement of the plant defense system and alleviation of CCA
phytotoxicity by enhancing the plant biomass of the seedlings
of tree species. The NPK also improved the accumulation of Cu,
Cr, and As in the root, stem, and leaves of Acacia auriculiformis
and Casuarina equisetifolia. These plants could be used as
phytoaccumulators for remediation of CCA compounds on
application of NPK. However, further studies are required on
the evaluation of the phytoremediation efficiency of these tree
species in field conditions.
Acknowledgement
The authors are grateful to Bangalore University, Bengaluru,
India for extending research facilities for conduct of these studies.