Case Report
Traditional Wisdom of Ayurvedic Dietetics Amalgamated with Modern Approaches: A Pivotal Case Study
Darshane P and Pandit A
Assistant Professor, Department of Ayurved and Yog, Tilak Maharashtra Vidyapeeth, Pune, India
*Corresponding author:Priya Darshane, Department of Ayurved and Yog, Tilak Maharashtra Vidyapeeth, Pune, India E-mail Id:darshane.priya20@gmail.com
Article Information:Submission: 26/02/2024; Accepted: 18/03/2024; Published: 20/03/2024
Copyright:©2024 Darshane P, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Abstract
Every country has its own tradition. Similarly India treasures its valued medical tradition of Ayurveda, which is appropriately called as the science of life (Ayu: Life, Veda: knowledge). Ayurveda which has been penned down 3000 years back by Indian sages explicitly elucidates the accurate dietary patterns,
therapeutic food combinations and culinary rules for healthy longevity of humans. It doesn’t stop here but provides the precise dietary and lifestyle regimens to lead a dignified and valued life. This wisdom when combined with modern nutrition support, proves to be a wonderful tool of therapeutic management.
In this case research paper, the power of certain significant traditional Indian food combinations along with modern nutrition techniques have been elucidated clearly in a particular case of type II diabetes mellitus. It talks about various therapeutic food combinations implemented and significance given to food energies in the case undertaken.
This case research results will definitely prove beneficial to the health care industry, food industry and nutraceutical field as well for better treatment modalities.
In this case research paper, the power of certain significant traditional Indian food combinations along with modern nutrition techniques have been elucidated clearly in a particular case of type II diabetes mellitus. It talks about various therapeutic food combinations implemented and significance given to food energies in the case undertaken.
This case research results will definitely prove beneficial to the health care industry, food industry and nutraceutical field as well for better treatment modalities.
Keywords:Ayurveda; Dietetics; Traditional wisdom; Diabetes type II; Therapeutic food
Introduction
Every country treasures its own traditions. Similarly India, a
pristine beauty of nature also cherishes its very own and valuable
tradition of healing; known as ‘Ayurveda’. Ayurveda, as the name
means the science of life (Ayu: Life and Veda: Knowledge) [1].
Ayurvedais a upaveda of Atharvaveda; one of the significant Vedas
from four Vedas namely Rugveda, Samaveda, Yajurveda and
Atharvaveda. This upaveda explicably states various herbs, food
ingredients and their combinations used as therapeutic means of
healing human disorders in the most natural way. This doesn’t end
here. Ayurveda also describes in detail the ideal system of eating food
and ultimately leading a life [2]. Ayurveda is one of the great gifts of
the sages of ancient India to the mankind. It is truly a holistic and
integral medical system [3].
Similarly modern nutrition science also exhibits immense efficacy
for disease treatment and for healthy longevity. Again in today’s era
modern nutrition science is not limited to calculating nutrients,
measuring calories and other needs of the body but also extends its
boundaries by considering the human genetic makeup as well. All these
endeavors are for better efficacy of therapeutic dietary modification
and overall treatment module. But this personalized nutrition care
plan is from modern perspectives of dietetics and exhibits certain
lacunas such as technical difficulties while implementing the plan
bilaterally.
As discussed above, ancient Indian medicinal science has certain
uniqueness which aids in personalized nutrition. This exactly is by
considering individual’s prakriti (as termed in Sanskrit)or body
constitution. If we as nutrition experts consider this fact and design
individual’s diet plan, the odds of its efficacy are superior and
definite. Unfortunately this novel but most needed perception of
diet designing by considering person’s prakritiis highly neglected
in current scenario by dieticians following western knowledge
of dietetics. Hence the need arises to sensitize them and the other
medical fraternity to reconsider this ancient wisdom of Ayurveda as
primary line of treatment in the health care provision to the needy
segment.
A. Ayurveda and Nutrition
Ayurveda specifically stresses that our diet must be according to the design or nature of our bodies. If the nature of the food is in harmony with the nature of our body then only the food ingested will be efficiently processed by our digestive tract. So, to understand the correct diet for oneself, it is important to understand the following:
Ayurveda specifically stresses that our diet must be according to the design or nature of our bodies. If the nature of the food is in harmony with the nature of our body then only the food ingested will be efficiently processed by our digestive tract. So, to understand the correct diet for oneself, it is important to understand the following:
1. The nature of the person
2. The nature of the food
2. The nature of the food
Understanding the patient’s prakriti helps nutrition experts to
design the food profile that nourishes and maintains that nature and
also to recover from the disease.
Ayurveda uses two fundamental concepts to understand a
person’s nature or prakriti.
1. Tridosha/ three energetic forces: Vata, Pitta and Kapha
2. Triguna/ three qualities: Raja, Satva and Tama
2. Triguna/ three qualities: Raja, Satva and Tama
Triguna influence the psyche, which shapes our behavioral
traits, while tridosha are responsible for the physical characteristics.
Every person has a dominant doshaand guna. Understanding of
this is significant. All of theseabove-mentioned parameters play
an important role in designing our diet, which is a major source of
nourishment [4].
Thus, in the current case study, this novel approach of designing
a diet was implemented and the results obtained were highly positive.
This implements that the current approach of treatment is far better
that the conventional one where a combinational treatment of
Ayurveda and Dietetics is seldom used.
B. Methodology
1. Case
A 54 years old obese (stage I) female presented with 6 years history of both type II DM and stage II hypertension. She markedly exhibited central obesity and long-standing psychological stress owing to family disturbances. She exhibited past history (2 years back) of stage IV breast CA with skeletal secondaries for which she had administered 6 cycles of chemotherapy with carboplatin drug followed by 6 months of oral chemotherapy with cycloxan drug in combination with MTX. Her prognosis for anticancer drugs was perceived as good and currently all her secondaries are inactive and thus maintained only on mega doses of antioxidants. Currently she was stabilized on antihypertensive, hypoglycemic drugs and statins at the time of approach to the nutritionist in OPD sector.
1. Case
A 54 years old obese (stage I) female presented with 6 years history of both type II DM and stage II hypertension. She markedly exhibited central obesity and long-standing psychological stress owing to family disturbances. She exhibited past history (2 years back) of stage IV breast CA with skeletal secondaries for which she had administered 6 cycles of chemotherapy with carboplatin drug followed by 6 months of oral chemotherapy with cycloxan drug in combination with MTX. Her prognosis for anticancer drugs was perceived as good and currently all her secondaries are inactive and thus maintained only on mega doses of antioxidants. Currently she was stabilized on antihypertensive, hypoglycemic drugs and statins at the time of approach to the nutritionist in OPD sector.
2. Nutritional Treatment
Here primarily her nutrition screening was carried out as per modern dietetics science protocol. This exhibited following results.
Here primarily her nutrition screening was carried out as per modern dietetics science protocol. This exhibited following results.
Nutrition screening at the time of approach to nutritionist
(2nd February 2022)
1. Anthropometry: UBW (Usual body wt): 79 Kg, Ht (Height):
5.5” IBW (Ideal body wt): 57 kg, ABW (Adjusted body wt): 66 kg
2. Laboratory analysis: HTN: 130/90, Lipid profile: within acceptable range, Fasting BSL: 97, HbA1C: 7, Hb: 8, ALP: 122, CA 13.5: 22
3. Medications: Radifree, Losar 50, Envill M (Vildaliptin 50, Metformin 500- BBF, BD), Rasave A 75, Corcal 500, Becosule, PanD 40, Gabapentin 100
4. H/O diseases/ surgeries: stage IV Breast CA with skeletal secondaries currently inactivated with chemo cycles (IV and oral administration), no surgeries history
5. Allergies: NA
6. Psychosocial history: Spouse passed away 3 years back with prostate CA, currently she lives with her 21 yrs old daughter. She is a homemaker.
7. Physical appearance: broad and heavy body built up, obese stage I, thick, smooth skin and hair, large strained eyes, slow in reactions and physical activities, explains deep sleep with loud snores, cold intolerance, frequent mild URTI
8. Diet history: heavy consumption of cab rich food, less hunger, less consumption of fluids, proteins and fiber. Disrupted meal timings and inactivity, No other habits.
1. Anthropometry: UBW (Usual body wt): 79 Kg, Ht (Height):
5.5” IBW (Ideal body wt): 57 kg, ABW (Adjusted body wt): 66 kg
2. Laboratory analysis: HTN: 130/90, Lipid profile: within acceptable range, Fasting BSL: 97, HbA1C: 7, Hb: 8, ALP: 122, CA 13.5: 22
3. Medications: Radifree, Losar 50, Envill M (Vildaliptin 50, Metformin 500- BBF, BD), Rasave A 75, Corcal 500, Becosule, PanD 40, Gabapentin 100
4. H/O diseases/ surgeries: stage IV Breast CA with skeletal secondaries currently inactivated with chemo cycles (IV and oral administration), no surgeries history
5. Allergies: NA
6. Psychosocial history: Spouse passed away 3 years back with prostate CA, currently she lives with her 21 yrs old daughter. She is a homemaker.
7. Physical appearance: broad and heavy body built up, obese stage I, thick, smooth skin and hair, large strained eyes, slow in reactions and physical activities, explains deep sleep with loud snores, cold intolerance, frequent mild URTI
8. Diet history: heavy consumption of cab rich food, less hunger, less consumption of fluids, proteins and fiber. Disrupted meal timings and inactivity, No other habits.
Nutritional Analysis:
Anemic, Type II diabetic and stage I hypertensive patient as
related to chronic uncontrolled hyperglycemia, stage I obesity and
poor dietary and lifestyle practices as evidenced by lab data and
nutritional screening. The patient exhibits the dominance of kapha
prakritias evidenced by anthropometric data and physiological
appearance from nutritional screening.Dietary Treatment:
The patient was undertaken for the treatment of anemia, weight
loss, BSL and BP control and avoidance of cancer relapse/ activation.
The treatment as per modern science takes into consideration
only the basic and advanced proximate principles of diet but when
the treatment is provided with an integral approach it considers the
body constitution of the person; and here under consideration is her
kaphadominant prakriti.The diet for this patient was designed with the aim of restoring
iron imbalance, reduction in body weight (excess fat loss), lowering
of blood pressure and regularizing her fasting and post prandial BSL.
For this food that help to restore the balance of disrupted kapha
dosha were prescribed rather than just considering macronutrients
and micronutrients needs.
This patient with kapha prakriti required less carbohydrate but
more proteins and fiber in her diet. Also she needed to regulate her
eating patterns by including fasting episodes in a day. Also combining
carbohydrates with astringent, pungent and bitter tastes helps to
restore kapha dosha. Inclusion of ginger, pepper, lemon, citrus fruits
helps to melt down excess kapha.
Her prescribed dietary pattern included three major meals. Each
major meal was designed to provide 400 K calories and 15 gm proteins;
together a day’s diet provided 1500 Kcal and 45-50 gm good quality
plant based proteins. Here carbohydrates were distributed as per her
diabetic medication schedule. Her diet was rich in iron loaded foods
and vitamin C specific foods. Apart from these macronutrients, her
diet was low fat and low sodium and high fiber diet for hypertensive
precautions. She was also maintained on 200 ml skimmed desi cow’s
milk daily with a protein supplement (Proteinex DM).
To restore her kapha balance, she was provided with a food chart
where foods allowed in kapha dominance are allowed such as fewer
cereals, more pulses, legumes, certain vegetables, fruits, nuts and
oilseeds etc.
Some of them among vegetables are leafy vegetables, okra,
peppers, tomatoes, beetroot, beet greens, carrot, radish, cauliflower,
cabbage, asparagus, bitter gourd, among fruits are berries, apples,
citrus fruits, melons, figs, pear, pomegranate etc., among cereals are
millets (jowar, bajra, ragi, rajgeera) and less of wheat and rice, among
pulses are whole and sprouted legumes and all dals in liberal amount,
among nuts and oilseeds are dried figs, prunes, almonds, pumpkin
seeds, cucumber seeds, sesame seeds, flaxseeds, niger seeds and less
groundnuts, coconut, among oils are safflower and sunflower oil and
cow’s ghee, among dairy products are cow’s skim milk and fresh curd
or buttermilk, no lassi or sour curds.
Apart from these the patient was asked to strictly follow the satvik
vegetarian diet as mentioned above. Also, the incorporation of spices
and condiments were limited to only dhana-jeerapd, pepper pd and
fresh condiments such as ginger (fresh and dry), coriander, lemon,
turmeric, asafetida and garlic, red chilli pd and garammasala in
limited amount. Apart from these certain functional foods were also
included such as fennel-cucumber seeds- pumpkin seeds-flax seeds
mukhwas, jeera-meera-mint buttermilk and soaked fenugreek seeds
in a specified amounts.
Also, very significantly a primary counseling was conducted on
patient to incorporate positive vibrations while cooking and eating
food. These vibrations would add purity and healing power in
foods for absolute benefit. This remained the main area of focus in
counseling the patient.
Physical Activity:
Daily 30 minutes of positive meditation, 10 minutes of Pranayama
and 45 minutes of steady walk on flat surface was suggested. The same
routine with periodic caloric modifications was followed by patient
for 6 months.Discussion and Results
After following the above-mentioned diet along with lifestyle
changes and thought process change, the results obtained after sixth
month were extraordinary and are as under.
Body wt: 62 kg
BSL: fasting 91, PP 110
HbA1C: 5
Hb: 12.50 mmHg
Lipid profile: within normal range
RFT and LFT: within normal range
ALP: 77 IU/L
CA 15.3: 15 U/ml
BSL: fasting 91, PP 110
HbA1C: 5
Hb: 12.50 mmHg
Lipid profile: within normal range
RFT and LFT: within normal range
ALP: 77 IU/L
CA 15.3: 15 U/ml
The above results exhibit excellent blood sugar control, fairly
good hemoglobin status, reduced and acceptable body weight, ALP
which is an indicator of skeletal malfunctioning is absolutely normal
and also breast cancer marker (CA 15.3) is also in normal range.
Weight loss was a sustained one and the chances of regaining
weight are minimal on the above-mentioned plan. Also adhering
to this routine, the patient exhibited better immunity and tolerance
to environmental changes. Her physical expressions were crisp and
fresh.
Her recent pet scan also exhibited inactive skeletal secondaries.
Currently she weighs 63 kg with all parameters in normal range and
now she is sustained only on antihypertensive drugs. She has been
taken off the antihypoglycemic therapy and statins treatment now.
This is a huge achievement in dietetics’ profession.
Concluding Remarks
The above discussed case was the case of chronic grade I obesity
accompanied by type II DM and stage I HTN with past history of
metastatic breast cancer of which currently the bone metastasis
exhibits inactive lesions.
The diet and lifestyle changes were extremely useful in attaining the objectives of the treatment and avoidance of relapse.
This novel and integral perspective of treatment where traditional therapy has been implanted with modern approaches has proven to be a successful and promising therapeutic module in health care provision. This needs more focus and more advanced research is needed to explore further margins of holistic treatment.
The diet and lifestyle changes were extremely useful in attaining the objectives of the treatment and avoidance of relapse.
This novel and integral perspective of treatment where traditional therapy has been implanted with modern approaches has proven to be a successful and promising therapeutic module in health care provision. This needs more focus and more advanced research is needed to explore further margins of holistic treatment.